Bert Thomas Batchelor
kAm~? E96 gE9 @7 y2?F2CJ[ `hca[ E96 H@C=5 H2D 2E H2C] xE H2D 2 4@=5 |:DD:DD:AA: >@C?:?8 :? E96 E@H? @7 |6C:5:2?] pE dibd[ '6C?:46 rF=36CED@? q2E496=@C 82G6 3:CE9 E@ E96:C D64@?5 @7 E9C66 49:=5C6?i 2 323J 3@J E96J ?2>65[ “q6CE”]k^Am
kAmw:D 72E96C[ |2CD92= }62= q2E496=@C[ H2D D6CG:?8 :? E96 &$ p:C u@C46] q6CE =:G65 2== @G6C p>6C:42 2?5 6G6? :? w@<<2:5@[ y2A2?[ :? 9:D J@FE9] {2E6C[ E96 72>:=J 3@F89E 2 72C> :? |25:D@? !2C:D9[ {@F:D:2?2[ ?62C “q62C {2<6”] %9C@F89@FE 9:D D49@@= J62CD[ q6CE H@C<65 @? E96 72>:=J 72C> 2?5 6G6? 925 2 ;@3 4=62C:?8 =2?5 F?E:= 8C25F2E:?8 7C@> %2==F=29 w:89 $49@@=]k^Am
kAmw6 H2D 2446AE65 2E }@CE9H6DE6C? $E2E6 &?:G6CD:EJ :? }2E49:E@496D[ {@F:D:2?2[ H96C6 96 >2;@C65 :? |:4C@3:@=@8J 2?5 >:?@C65 :? pCE] sFC:?8 4@==686[ 96 D6CG65 2D 2FI:=:2CJ =2H 6?7@C46>6?E[ 3682? $r&qp 5:G:?8[ H2D 2 4@>A6E:E:G6 D9@@E6C[ H2D 2 3@I6C[ 2?5 6G6? H@C<65 7@C y:> r=2C< 9:>D6=7 2E “r=2C<’D rFDE@> vF?D” 2D 2 >249:?:DE 2?5 8F?D>:E9] w@H6G6C[ 96 76=E 9:D 4@F?ECJ ?66565 9:>] w6 AFE 9:D DEF5:6D @? 9@=5 2?5 6?=:DE65 :? E96 &?:E65 $E2E6D |2C:?6 r@CAD] q6CE 8C25F2E65 H:E9 !=2E@@? `cd 7C@> E96 $2? s:68@ |r#s] w6 E96? 2EE6?565 #2:56C D49@@= 2?5 D6CG65 2D 2 7:6=5 H:C6>2? 5FC:?8 E96 ':6E?2> (2C :? E96 `DE q2EE2=:@?[ hE9 |2C:?6D[ u=66E |2C:?6 u@C46] xE H2D 5FC:?8 E9:D E:>6 E96 F?:E 3642>6 <?@H? 2D E96 :?72>@FD[ “(2=<:?8 s625”] %9:D H2D 5FC:?8 E96 62C=:6DE A@:?E @7 p>6C:42’D @44FA2E:@? :? $@FE962DE pD:2] q6CE H2D AC6D6?E65 H:E9 2 >F=E:EF56 @7 2H2C5D :?4=F5:?8 #:7=6 tIA6CE] rA=] q2E496=@C H2D :?G@=G65 :? >2?J DF446DD7F= >:DD:@?D :?4=F5:?8 “~A6C2E:@? $E2C=:89E”] q2E49 DFDE2:?65 D6G6C2= :?;FC:6D :? E96 |2C:?6D[ 3FE C67FD65 2?J 9@?@CD @C AC:G:=686D E92E H6C6 @776C65j 96 H@F=5?’E =62G6 9:D 3F55:6D] p7E6C 36:?8 9@?@C23=J 5:D492C865[ q6CE ?@E @?=J C6EFC?65 E@ }$&[ 3FE 2=D@ C6EFC?65 E@ 2 >F49\492?865 p>6C:42] {2E6C[ 96 3682? 72C>:?8 9:D @H? =2?5] w6 =@G65 E96 72C> =:76 3642FD6 :E 2==@H65 9:> E@ AFCDF6 9:D @E96C A2DD:@?D =:<6 =@?8 C2?86 D9@@E:?8[ A9@E@8C2A9J[ <?:76 >2<:?8[ DEF5J:?8 9:DE@CJ[ =62E96CH@C<[ 7=J 7:D9:?8[ A@EE6CJ[ A2:?E:?8[ 9F?E:?8[ 42>A:?8 2?5 6G6? 3642>6 2? 9@?@C65 >6>36C @7 E96 }2E:G6 p>6C:42? $:@FI }2E:@?]k^Am
kAm(96? 96 C6E:C65 7C@> 9:D 72C>:?8 42C66C[ 96 3682? 6>A=@J>6?E E@ @?46 282:? AC@G:56 D6CG:46 E@ 9:D 4@>>F?:EJ :? E96 {@F:D:2?2 s6A2CE>6?E @7 p8C:4F=EFC6 2?5 E96 }#r$[ F?E:= 96 C6E:C65] xE H2D?’E =@?8 F?E:= 96 8@E 3@C65 H:E9 C6E:C6>6?E]]]282:?]]]2?5 H2D 2 564@C2E65 pC>65 $64FC:EJ $A64:2=:DE 7@C !:?<6CE@? 2E E96 J@F?8 286 ef[ F?E:= 7:?2==J C6E:C:?8 J62CD =2E6C FA@? E96 2CC:G2= @7 9:D 7:CDE 3@C? 8C2?5D@?]k^Am
kAmw:D 8C62E6DE A2DD:@? @7 2== H2D 96=A:?8 @E96CD] w6 56G@E65 9:D =:76 E@ y6DFD r9C:DE[ 2?5 H2D 2=H2JD 2E 2:5 E@ 2?J@?6 H9@ H2D :? ?665 @7 8F:52?46 H96E96C :E 36 DF3DE2?46 C6=2E65 @C 2 J@F?8 D@=5:6C H:E9 !%$s H9@ ;FDE ?66565 D@>6@?6 E@ =:DE6? E@ E96>] q6CE ?6G6C D2:5 “?@” E@ 2?J@?6 H9@ H2D 2D<:?8 7@C 96=A 2?5 H2?E65 E@ 96=A E96>D6=G6D] $6=7=6DD=J 2DD:DE:?8 D2556?65 72>:=:6D 5FC:?8 E:>6D @7 562E9 H2D 9:D >@DE ?@E6H@CE9J BF2=:EJ @7 25>:C2E:@?[k^Am
kAmw6 =@G65 E@ ;@<6 2C@F?5j 6?;@J A62467F= DF?D6EDj 62E |6I:42? 7@@5j H2E49 $@FE9A2C<j >2<6 DFC6 E96C6 H2D A=6?EJ @7 D2=E @? 9:D >62=Dj 5:D4FDD ?6HD[ H62E96C[ 2?5 A@=:E:4Dj A=2J H:E9 9:D 8C2?549:=5C6? 2?5 36 E96 A9@E@8C2A96C 2E E96:C 3:CE952J A2CE:6D] sC:G:?8[ EC2G6=:?8[ >FD:4 @7 2== 86?C6D W7C@> E96 vC2E67F= s625 E@ ~K2C< q=F68C2DD v@DA6=X[ }2E:G6 p>6C:42? 4F=EFC6[ EC2:?:?8 5@8D[ 8C@H:?8 C@D6D[ DEF5J:?8 E2C2?EF=2D[ =@42= H:=5=:76 3:@=@8J 2?5 3692G:@C[ 2DD:DE:?8 :? 9:D D@?’D $4@FE:?8 6G6?ED[ ?2AA:?8 @? C2:?J 52JD[ C6=@25:?8 2>>F?:E:@?[ 2?5 3@2E:?8]]]H6C6 ;FDE 2 76H @7 9:D @3D6DD:G6 :?E6C6DED]k^Am
kAmpE E96 E:>6 E9:D H2D HC:EE6?[ q6CE H2D DE:== E96 =2DE A6CD@? E@ =682==J <:== 2 362C[ 2D :E H2D @? E96 =2DE 52J @7 362C D62D@? :? E96 $E2E6 @7 {@F:D:2?2]k^Am
kAmp7E6C 7:89E:?8 2 =6?8E9J :==?6DD[ q6CE H2D E2<6? 9@>6 3J E96 {@C5 @? $2EFC52J[ |2J `d[ a_a`] w:D 52F89E6C[ {@C2[ 2?5 D@?[ u=6E49[ H6C6 9@=5:?8 9:D 92?5D :? v=6?H@@5 #68:@?2= |65:42= r6?E6C xr& :? (6DE |@?C@6[ {@F:D:2?2]k^Am
kAmw6 :D AC646565 :? 562E9 3J 9:D =@G:?8 A2C6?ED[ |]}] W“$2C86”^”q:8 q6CE”X 2?5 '6C?:46 q2E496=@Cj H:76[ y62?6EE6j =@G:?8 ?:646[ !2>6=2 qJC5 $2?56CDj 3C@E96C\:?\=2H[ %9@>2D (2J?6 qJC5j 2?5 9:D 8C2?5A2C6?ED[ %9@>2D |] 2?5 z2E6 q2E496=@C]k^Am
kAmw6 =62G6D E96 H@C=5 9:D D@?[ q6CE u] “u=6E49” q2E496=@C[ 52F89E6C\:?\=@G6[ {@C2 q2E496=@C[ 2?5 E96:C D@?D W9:D EC62DFC6DX[ y2IE@? z] q2E496=@C[ 286 D:I[ 2?5 r9C:DE:2? %] q2E496=@C[ 286 EH@j 2 =@G:?8 D:DE6C[ |2C:=J? v2:= qJC5j 2 =@G:?8 3C@E96C[ uC65C:4< }62= q2E496=@Cj 2 56G@E65 ?6A96H[ %9@>2D |] qJC5 2?5 H:76 r:?5Jj 2 =@G:?8 ?:646[ r2E9J %@@=6 2?5 9FD32?5[ t5j 9:D A6E v@=:2E9 $A:56C “w6?C:6EE2”j 2?5 2 9@DE @7 8C62E ?:646D 2?5 8C62E ?6A96HD]k^Am
kAmp== 2C6 2AAC64:2E65 E@ 2EE6?5] pD C6BF6DE65 @7 E96 56462D65[ ?@ >@FC?:?8 :D 2==@H65 2E E9:D 46=63C2E:@? @7 =:76]k^Am
kAmuF?6C2= D6CG:46D H6C6 AC@G:565 3J rC@E96CD\v=6?H@@5 uF?6C2= w@>6 :? %2==F=29[ {@F:D:2?2] p G:D:E2E:@? H2D 96=5 uC:52J[ |2J a`[ a_a`[ 7C@> e A]>] E@ h A]>] 2E rC@E96CD\v=6?H@@5 uF?6C2= w@>6] %96 7F?6C2= D6CG:46 H2D 96=5 $2EFC52J[ |2J aa[ a_a`[ 2E h 2]>] 2E rC@E96CD\v=6?H@@5 uF?6C2= w@>6] qFC:2= 7@==@H65 E96 7F?6C2= D6CG:46[ $2EFC52J[ |2J aa[ a_a`[ 2E w@==J $AC:?8D r6>6E6CJ :? |2CE:?[ {@F:D:2?2]k^Am
kAm“x? 42D6 x 5:6[ 5@?’E A=2J 2?J D25 DRoE] !=2J D@>6 (:==:6 }6=D@?”] \q6CEk^Am
kAms63@C29 y2J?6 {J=6Dk^Am
kAm!C:G2E6 u2>:=J |6>@C:2= vC2G6D:56 $6CG:46D 7@C |CD] s63@C29 y2J?6 {J=6D[ eb[ @7 (:??D3@C@[ H:== 36 `_ 2]>] $2EFC52J[ yF?6 `a[ a_a`[ 2E vH:? r6>6E6CJ :? |2?892> H:E9 #6G] #:4< pF=E>2? @77:4:2E:?8] x?E6C>6?E H:== 7@==@H 2E vH:? r6>6E6CJ :? |2?892>]k^Am
kAm|CD] {J=6D H2D 3@C? $6AE6>36C `[ `hdf[ :? #2JG:==6 2?5 A2DD65 2H2J @? yF?6 c[ a_a` :? (:??D3@C@] k^Am
kAm$96 :D AC646565 :? 562E9 3J 96C A2C6?ED[ t=HJ? r] {J=6D 2?5 uC2?46D s] {J=6D]k^Am
kAm$FCG:G@CD :?4=F56 96C 3C@E96C[ sC] (:==:2> t=HJ? {J=6Dj 2D H6== 2D 9@DE @7 72>:=J 2?5 7C:6?5D] k^Am
kAm|6>@C:2=D >2J 36 >256 E@ |2?892> q2AE:DE r9FC49 |6>@C:2= uF?5]k^Am
kAm':D:E2E:@? 7@C 72>:=J 2?5 7C:6?5D H:== 36 7C@> e A]>] F?E:= g A]>] uC:52J[ yF?6 ``[ a_a`[ 2E |2?892> q2AE:DE r9FC49]k^Am
kAm~?=:?6 C68:DECJ^4@?5@=6?46Di k2 9C67lQ9EEAi^^HHH]>F=962C?7F?6C2=9@>6]4@>QmHHH]>F=962C?7F?6C2=9@>6]4@>k^2mk^Am
kAm|F=962C? uF?6C2= w@>6 \ (:??D3@C@k^Am
kAmt5H2C5 ~856? tCH:?k^Am
kAmuF?6C2= D6CG:46D 7@C qC@] t5H2C5 ‘t55:6’ tCH:?[ fa[ @7 (:??D3@C@[ H6C6 96=5 @? uC:52J[ yF?6 c[ a_a` 2E a A]>] :? E96 D2?4EF2CJ @7 y:886C pA@DE@=:4 r9FC49 H:E9 qC@] |:<6 w2==[ qC@] {:?562= vC66C[ 2?5 qC@] wFC3J w:EE @77:4:2E:?8] x?E6C>6?E H2D :? y:886C v2C56? @7 |6>@C:6D F?56C E96 5:C64E:@? @7 *@F?8’D r@>>F?:EJ |6>@C:2= uF?6C2= w@>6]k^Am
kAmt55:6 H2D 3@C? @? yF=J ac[ `hcg :? y:886C E@ E96 F?:@? @7 (9:E tCH:? 2?5 ~=:G:2 !6CCJ tCH:?] w6 D6CG65 9:D 4@F?ECJ 2D 2 &?:E65 $E2E6D |2C:?6 7C@> `heg F?E:= `hf_ 2D 2 7@CH2C5 @3D6CG6C H:E9 2? :?72?ECJ 4@>A2?J 5FC:?8 E96 ':6E?2> (2C] p7E6C C6EFC?:?8 7C@> E96 D6CG:46 :? `hf_[ 96 >2CC:65 E96 =@G6 @7 9:D =:76 H:E9 H9@> 96 DA6?E 2=>@DE d` J62CD 2?5 C2:D65 7@FC 9:89=J DF446DD7F= 2?5 8C62E =@@<:?8 49:=5C6?] k^Am
kAmx? `hfe 96 H2D 32AE:K65 :?E@ E96 r9FC49 @7 r9C:DE 2?5 3642>6 2 G:8:=2?E D6CG2?E @7 E96 {@C5] $@@?[ 96 3642>6 2 AC62496C 2?5 2 E62496C @7 D4C:AEFC6D[ 6G6?EF2==J @C52:?65 2D 2? 6=56C :? E96 y:886C r9FC49 @7 r9C:DE] w6 DA6?E E96 >2;@C:EJ @7 9:D =:76 H@C<:?8 7@C E96 {@C5 H:E9 6G6CJE9:?8 E92E 96 925]k^Am
kAmw6 A2DD65 7C@> E9:D =:76 @? |2J b`[ a_a` 2E 9:D 9@>6 :? y:886C DFCC@F?565 3J 9:D H:76 2?5 49:=5C6?] w6 :D AC646565 :? 562E9 3J 9:D A2C6?ED[ (9:E 2?5 ~=:G:2 tCH:?j 2?5 3C@E96CD #:492C5 tCH:?[ y@9? (2==246 tCH:?[ 2?5 tC?6DE s6':==6 tCH:?] k^Am
kAm$FCG:G@CD =67E E@ 496C:D9 9:D >6>@CJ 2C6 9:D H:76[ yF5J tCH:?j D@?D[ (9:E tCH:? 2?5 H:76 |2CJ[ |@CC6== tCH:? 2?5 H:76 ':4E@C:2[ 2?5 y6C6>:29 tCH:? 2?5 H:76 $92J=2j 52F89E6C[ #@I2??6 tCH:?j 3C@E96CD[ {6=2?5 tCH:? 2?5 H:76 (2?52 2?5 qCF46 tCH:? 2?5 H:76 #@??:6j D:DE6CD[ q6G6C=J r92>36CD 2?5 9FD32?5 s@? 2?5 !2> |29@?6J 2?5 9FD32?5 s2CC6?j 8C2?549:=5C6?[ p>2?52 '256?[ y24@3 tCH:?[ pFEF>? q2:=6J[ t>>2 r=2:C6 tCH:?[ p=6I2?56C tCH:?[ vC2JD@? w2J6D tCH:?[ 2?5 r92C=J ~=:G:2 tCH:?j 2?5 8C62E\8C2?5D@?D[ !C6DE@? '256?[ w2CC:D@? '256?[ 2?5 wF8@ '256?] w6 2=D@ =62G6D 369:?5 2 9@DE @7 ?:646D[ ?6A96HD[ 72>:=J[ 2?5 7C:6?5D]k^Am
kAm!2==362C6CD H6C6 qC25J y@?6D[ |:429 (:=496C[ y24@3 tCH:?[ vC68 %23@C[ zJ=6 {6q=2?4[ 2?5 #J2? w:EE] k^Am
kAmw@?@C2CJ A2==362C6CD H6C6 qC25 r=:6EE[ s2G:5 (:=496C[ {6G: |:?496H[ 2?5 $92?6 |@4<] k^Am
kAm%96 72>:=J C646:G65 7C:6?5D 7@C G:D:E2E:@? @? %9FCD52J[ yF?6 b[ a_a` 7C@> d A]>] – h A]>] 2E *@F?8’D r@>>F?:EJ |6>@C:2= uF?6C2= w@>6] k^Am
kAmk2 9C67lQ9EEAi^^HHH]J@F?8D4@>>F?:EJ]4@>QmHHH]J@F?8D4@>>F?:EJ]4@>k^2mk^Am
kAm#@J {J?? tK6==k^Am
kAmuF?6C2= D6CG:46D 7@C #@J {J?? tK6==[ fb[ _7 }6H6==E@? H6C6 ` A]>] uC:52J[ yF?6 c[ a_a`:? s6??2C5 u:CDE }2E:@?2= uF?6C2= w@>6 r92A6=\(:??D3@C@ H:E9 qC@ #2?5J {66 @77:4:2E:?8] x?E6C?>6?E 7@==@H65 :? {68:@? |6>@C:2= r6>6E6CJ\}6H6==E@? H:E9 |:=:E2CJ w@?@CD[ G:D:E2E:@? H2D 7C@> `_ 2]>] F?E:= D6CG:46 E:>6 uC:52J 2E E96 7F?6C2= 9@>6]k^Am
kAm|C] #@J 2 >6>36C @7 $J42>@C6 q2AE:DE r9FC49 \u6CC:52J A2DD65 2H2J |2J b_[ a_a`[ :? %2==F=29] p &?:E65 $E2E6D pC>J ':6E?2> (2C G6E6C2? C646:G65 ?F>6C@FD 2 4@>>6?52E:@?D 2D H6== 2D 2 !FCA=6 w62CE[ 2?5 p C6E:C65 @77D9@C6 >6492?:4 27E6C H9:49 96 5C@G6 2 ECF4< 7@C >2?J J62CD] k^Am
kAmw6 H2D AC646565 :? 562E9[ 3J 9:D A2C6?ED (:==:6 2?5 {@F:D6 tK6==j H:76[ {F=2 y62? tK6==j EH@ 3C@E96CD[ q:==J tK6== 2?5 %C2G:D tK6==j 2?5 2 D:DE6C t=2:?6 t2>6D]k^Am
kAmw6 :D DFCG:G65 3J E9C66 D@?D[ #@J {J?? tK6==[ yC] @7 }6H6==E@?[ 52F89E6C\:?\=2H v:?2 tK6==j (:==:6 y@6 tK6== @7 }6H6==E@?[ 2?5 s6??:D tK6== @7 ':52=:2j 3C@E96C[ y@9? #@36CE tK6== 2?5 9:D H:76 $2>2? @7 y@?6D3@C@[ {pj EH@ D:DE6CD q6EEJ s62E@? @7 $9C6G6A@CE[ 2?5 $J3:= pC?@=5 2?5 9FD32?5 |:==2C5 @7 y@?6D3@C@[ {pj 8C2?549:=5C6?[ s2>:6? {J?? tK6== 2?5 y62?:6 |:=J?? $<J tK6==j D6G6C2= ?:646D 2?5 ?6A96HD]k^Am
kAm!2==362C6CD H6C6 y2>6D t2>6D[ (:==:6 y@6 tK6==[ v6?6 {@C5[ r@=6 w:4<:?83@EE@>[ y2>6D v2C5?6C[ 2?5 s2G:5 v@@5H:?]k^Am
kAmw@?@C2CJ !2==362C6CD H6C6 rFCE:D q:==>6:6C 2?5 |24926= $EC:4<=2?5]k^Am
kAm~?=:?6 C68:DECJ^4@?5@=6?46D 2E k2 9C67lQ9EEAi^^HHH]56??2C57:CDE?2E:@?2=]4@>QmHHH]56??2C57:CDE?2E:@?2=]4@>k^2m U?3DAjk^Am
kAms2=6 !2C<6Ck^Am
kAms2=6 !2C<6C[ e_[ @7 (:??D3@C@ A2DD65 7C@> E9:D =:76 uC:52J[ yF?6 c[ a_a`[ :? (:??D3@C@] w6 H2D 3@C? E@ E96 F?:@? @7 #@J !2C<6C 2?5 q:==:6 $F6 pC?@=5 !2C<6C y2?F2CJ ``[ `he`[ :? (:??D3@C@]k^Am
kAms2=6[ 2 }2GJ '6E6C2?[ 2?5 2 |:==HC:89E H2D AC646565 :? 562E9 3J 9:D A2C6?ED[ 52F89E6C w2??2 v\6?6 !2C<6C 2?5 96C F?3@C? 49:=5[ 9:D 8C2?549:=5]k^Am
kAms2=6 :D DFCG:G65 3J 9:D 3C@E96C |:4<6J !2C<6Cj D:DE6CDi |2CE92 s67:?5:?6 2?5 s63C2 !2C<6Cj @?6 8C2?549:=5j >2? ?:646D[ ?6A96HD[ 72>:=J 2?5 7C:6?5D]k^Am
kAm~?=:?6 4@?5@=6?46D >2J 36 >256 2E k2 9C67lQ9EEAi^^HHH]56??2C57:CDE?2E:@?2=]4@>QmHHH]56??2C57:CDE?2E:@?2=]4@>k^2m ]k^Am
kAmz6??6E9 u2J !6E6CDk^Am
kAm$6CG:46D 46=63C2E:?8 E96 =:76 @7 z6??6E9 u2J !6E6CD[ H6C6 96=5 2E uqr rC@HG:==6[ `e_ wHJ] dfg[ rC@HG:==6 @? |@?52J[ |2J b`[a_a`[ 2E `` 2]>] H:E9 !2DE@C (256 r@<6C[ !2DE@C %6CCJ v2?6J[ 2?5 !2DE@C r2C= vF=56 @77:4:2E:?8] x?E6C>6?E 7@==@H65 :? rC@HG:==6 |2D@?:4 r6>E6CJ F?56C E96 5:C64E:@? @7 s6??2C5 u:CDE }2E:@?2= uF?6C2= w@>6] ':D:E2E:@? H2D 7C@> `_\`` 2]>] 2E E96 49FC49]k^Am
kAmz6??6E9 u2J !6E6CD H2D 3@C? @? s646>36C b[ `hbd[ E@ 9:D AC@F5 A2C6?ED v2C=2?5 2?5 |23=6 (C@E6? !6E6CD 2E E96:C 9@>6 @? uC6?49 %FC? #@25 @FED:56 @7 rC@HG:==6[ {p] w6 6?E6C65 E96 AC6D6?46 @7 9:D $2G:@C @? uC:52J[ |2J ag[ a_a`[ 2E 9:D 9@>6 DFCC@F?565 3J 9:D =@G:?8 72>:=J] z6??6E9 H2D AC646565 :? 562E9 3J 9:D =@G:?8 A2C6?ED[ 2?5 9:D 3C@E96CD p==6? “!6E6” !6E6CD 2?5 y2>6D “s@4” !6E6CD]k^Am
kAmz6??6E9 8C25F2E65 7C@> rC@HG:==6 w:89 $49@@= :? E96 4=2DD @7 `hdc] w6 H6?E @? E@ D6CG6 :? E96 &$ pC>J 2?5 E96 &$ pC>J #6D6CG6D] w6 >2CC:65 E96 =@G6 @7 9:D =:76[ q6EEJ !:6C46[ @? $6AE6>36C c[ `hdf] z6??6E9 H2D s624@? t>6C:EFD 2E uqr rC@HG:==6 2?5 D6CG65 :? ?F>6C@FD A@D:E:@?D 2E E96 rC@HG:==6 |2D@?:4 {@586] w6 C6E:C65 27E6C bc J62CD 7C@> p%% 2D 2 !q) x?DE2==6C]k^Am
kAmz6??6E9 ?6G6C >6E 2 DEC2?86C 2?5 =@G65 E@ >2<6 A6@A=6 =2F89] w6 H2D 2=H2JD E96 =:76 @7 E96 A2CEJ H96? 72>:=J 2?5 7C:6?5D 82E96C65] z6??6E9 2?5 q6EEJ H6C6 DA@?D@CD 7@C >2?J J@FE9 42>AD E@ v=@C:6E2[ }| 2?5 E@ r2CD@? }6H>2? &?:G6CD:EJ :? y6776CD@? r:EJ[ %6??6DD66] z6??6E9 2=D@ H6?E @? ?F>6C@FD >:DD:@? EC:AD E@ E6== @E96CD 23@FE y6DFD] w6 =@G65 <:5D 2?5 2=H2JD 925 42?5J E@ 8:G6 @FE :? 49FC49]k^Am
kAmw6 :D DFCG:G65 3J 9:D =@G:?8 H:76 @7 >@C6 E92? eb J62CD[ q6EEJ !:6C46 !6E6CD] w:D 49:=5C6?i %@> Wp??2X !6E6CD[ {:Dé WqC6?EX t==6?56C[ 2?5 q64<J W#2?5JX qC@H?] w:D 8C2?549:=5C6?i {2FC2 W%@55X pE49:D@?[ y2C65 WzC:DE:?2X !6E6CD[ '2=6CJ !6E6CD[ |@==J t==6?56C 2?5 7:2?4é[ (:== v62C:8[ r@C6J t==6?56C[ x2? sC2?6[ #@DD W|255:X t==6?56C[ |:DD@FC: Wy@?2E92?X vC2J] w:D 8C62E\8C2?549:=5C6?i |2EE96H !6E6CD 2?5 {F4J !6E6CD]k^Am
kAmw6 :D 2=D@ DFCG:G65 3J 9:D 3C@E96CDi #688:6 W$J3:=X !6E6CD[ #@J W{J?6EE6X !6E6CD[ 2?5 v2CJ !6E6CD] w:D D:DE6CDi {6?@C2 W{@F:DX p>6566[ {:==:2? W{2CCJX p?5C6HD[ z2C6? W#@?2=5X q6249] w:D D:DE6C\:?\=2Hi r92C=@EE6 !6E6CD] p?5 ?F>6C@FD ?:646D[ ?6A96HD[ 8C62E\?:646D[ 2?5 8C62E ?6A96HD]k^Am
kAm!2==362C6CD H6C6 %@?J p>@D[ x2? sC2?6[ qC6?E t==6?56C[ pD9=6J !6E6CD[ y2C65 !6E6CD[ 2?5 $4@EE !6E6CD] %96 9@?@C2CJ A2==362C6CD H6C6 %@55 pE49:D@?[ y@?2E92? vC2J[ y@9? r@C6J t==6?56C[ tG2? #@DD t==6?56C[ 2?5 E96 $6?:@C |6?’D $F?52J $49@@= 4=2DD 2?5 E96 s624@?D @7 uqr rC@HG:==6]k^Am
kAm%96 72>:=J H@F=5 =:<6 E@ E92?< E96 >6>36CD @7 uqr rC@HG:==6[ 2?5 E96 DE277 @7 t=2C2 r2C:?8 w@DA:46 7@C E96:C =@G:?8 42C6 5FC:?8 z6??6E9’D :==?6DD] (6 H@F=5 6DA64:2==J =:<6 E@ E92?< r@EJ (9:E2<6C[ #}[ p$}[ 2?5 #@D6 s:4<6?D[ r}p]k^Am
kAm%96 72>:=J C6BF6DED :? =:6F @7 7=@H6CD[ >6>@C:2=D >2J 36 >256 E@ $9C:?6CD w@DA:E2=[ @C E@ uqr rC@HG:==6 *@FE9 uF?5] k^Am
kAm~?=:?6 4@?5@=6?46D >2J 36 >256 2E k2 9C67lQ9EEAi^^HHH]56??2C57:CDE?2E:@?2=]4@>QmHHH]56??2C57:CDE?2E:@?2=]4@>k^2m ]k^Am
kAmr92C=:6 y6DD:6 $>:E9k^Am
kAm$6CG:46D 7@C r92C=:6 y6DD:6 $>:E9[ gg[ @7 #2JG:==6 H:== 36 96=5 2E ?@@?[ $2EFC52J[ yF?6 `a[ a_a`[ :? E96 r92A6= @7 s6??2C5 u:CDE }2E:@?2= uF?6C2= w@>6 – (:??D3@C@[ :?E6C?>6?E H:== 7@==@H 2E w2CC:D r6>6E6CJj G:D:E2E:@? H:== 36 7C@> `_ 2]>] F?E:= ?@@? AC:@C E@ E96 D6CG:46]k^Am
kAmr92C=:6 H2D 3@C? E@ E96 F?:@? @7 r=2F56 r=:7E@? $>:E9 2?5 q6F=29 p?86=:?6 !66GJ $>:E9 @? yF=J b`[ `hba[ :? u6CC:52J[ {p 2?5 A2DD65 7C@> E9:D =:76 yF?6 c[ a_a`[ 2E $E] uC2?4:D |65:42= r6?E6C :? |@?C@6[ {p] w6 H2D 2? 2G:5 @FE5@@CD>2?[ 2 962GJ 6BF:A>6?E @A6C2E@C[ 42CA6?E6C[ 2?5 2 8C62E 72E96C]k^Am
kAmr92C=:6 H2D AC646565 :? 562E9 3J 9:D D@? s6IE6C $>:E9j H:76 2?5 >@E96C @7 9:D 49:=5C6?[ q6EEJ y@ {:G=6J $>:E9j 2?5 H:76 q6C?:46 rFEC6C $>:E9]k^Am
kAmr92C=:6 :D DFCG:G65 3J H:76[ |2CJ $>:E9j 52F89E6C q=6?5:2 v2:= (2=<6Cj D@?Di {6D=:6 y@4< $>:E9 2?5 r=2F56 {66 $>:E9j DE6A\49:=5C6?i r92C=6D x?8C2> 2?5 s2?:<6C u=@J5j 6:89E 8C2?549:=5C6?j 6:89E66? 8C62E\8C2?549:=5C6?j 2?5 2 9@DE @7 72>:=J 2?5 7C:6?5D]k^Am
kAm~?=:?6 4@?5@=6?46D >2J 36 >256 2E k2 9C67lQ9EEAi^^HHH]56??2C57:CDE?2E:@?2=]4@>QmHHH]56??2C57:CDE?2E:@?2=]4@>k^2m ]k^Am
kAm'6=52 {@7E@? %6>A=6k^Am
kAmuF?6C2= D6CG:46 7@C '6=52 {@7E@? %6>A=6[ eh @7 (:??D3@C@ H6C6 96=5 2E `_ 2]>] $2EFC52J[ yF?6 c[ a_a` :? r2=G2CJ q2AE:DE r9FC49 :? v:=36CE H:E9 #6G] q@33J t?D>:?86C @77:4:2E:?8] x?E6C>6?E 7@==@H65 :? ~2<=6J r6>6E6CJ F?56C E96 5:C64E:@? @7 s6??2C5 u:CDE }2E:@?2= uF?6C2= w@>6 @7 (:??D3@C@] ':D:E2E:@? H2D 7C@> d\h A]>] uC:52J[ yF?6 c[ a_a` 2E r2=G2CJ q2AE:DE r9FC49]k^Am
kAm$96 H2D 3@C? E@ E96 F?:@? @7 wF6J !:6C46 2?5 {:==:6 {66 !6CCJ {@7E@? @? }@G6>36C ab[ `hd` :? (:??D3@C@ 2?5 A2DD65 7C@> E9:D =:76 yF?6 b[ a_a` 2E 96C C6D:56?46 :? (:??D3@C@] k^Am
kAm$96 H2D 2 >6>36C @7 r2=G2CJ q2AE:DE r9FC49 2?5 H@C<65 7@C @G6C bc J62CD 2E uC2?<=:? |65:42= r6?E6C 2D 2 !92C>24J %649?:4:2?] w6C A2DE:>6 H2D DA6?5:?8 E:>6 H:E9 96C 9FD32?5[ 49:=5C6?[ 8C2?549:=5C6? 2?5 D:DE6C]k^Am
kAm|CD] %6>A=6 :D DFCG:G65 3J 96C 9FD32?5 tC:4 %6>A=6 @7 (:??D3@C@j EH@ D@?D r925 y6DE6C 2?5 H:76 r2C>6? @7 (:??D3@C@ 2?5 tC:4 y6DE6C 2?5 H:76 |2CJ p??6 @7 v:=36CEj EH:? D:DE6C '652 (2=<6C 2?5 9FD32?5 $E6G6 @7 vC66?H6== $AC:?8Dj 7:G6 8C2?549:=5C6? w@==66 w:==:2C5 2?5 9FD32?5 $<J=2C @7 q2D<:?[ qC@5J z6DE6C[ {6D=:6 y6DE6C 3@E9 @7 v:=36CE[ w2G6? (@C< 2?5 9FD32?5 y@9? @7 (:??D3@C@ 2?5 w2??29 %2J=@C 2?5 7:2?46’ p=6I %9@C?E@? @7 (:??D3@C@j 2 9@DE @7 ?:646D[ ?6A96HD[ @E96C C6=2E:G6D 2?5 7C:6?5D]k^Am
kAm!2==362C6CD H6C6$92?6 r2CC[ #F3:6? y@?6D[ v6?6 {249?6J[ (2J?6 {@H6[ s2=6 |4{6>@C6 2?5 r9C:D (2==246]k^Am
kAmw@?@C2CJ A2==362C6CD H6C6 $<J=2C w:==:2C5[ qC@5J y6DE6C[ p=6I %9@C?E@? 2?5 y@9? (@C<]k^Am
kAm~?=:?6 4@?5@=6?46D >2J 36 >256 2E k2 9C67lQ9EEAi^^HHH]56??2C57:CDE?2E:@?2=]4@>QmHHH]56??2C57:CDE?2E:@?2=]4@>k^2m ]k^Am
kAms2G:5 #2J (9:E69625k^Am
kAmp |6>@C:2= ':D:E2E:@? $6CG:46 7@C s2G:5 #2J (9:E69625[ f`[ @7 (:??D3@C@ H2D 96=5 2E s6??2C5 u:CDE }2E:@?2= uF?6C2= %9FCD52J yF?6 b[ a_a` 2E `_\``2]>] H:E9 2 |6>@C:2= $6CG:46 7@==@H:?8 2E }@CE962DE {@F:D:2?2 '6E6C2?D r6>6E6CJ :? #2JG:==6 2E ?@@?]k^Am
kAms2G:5 H2D 3@C? E@ E96 F?:@? @7 |6=G:? 2?5 $J3:= (9:E69625 s646>36C b_[ `hd_[ :? w@33D[ }|] 2?5 A2DD65 7C@> E9:D =:76 27E6C 2 3C:67 :==?6DD |2J ah[ a_a`[ 2E !=2?E2E:@? |2?@C :?k^Am
kAm(:??D3@C@]k^Am
kAms2G:5[ 2 &]$] pC>J '6E6C2?[ H2D 2 >6>36C @7 E96 q2AE:DE u2:E9[ H@C<65 :? E96 ~:=7:6=5 2?5 H2D 2 3FE496C]k^Am
kAms2G:5 H2D AC646565 :? 562E9 3J 9:D A2C6?ED[ 2?5 E9C66 3C@E96CDi $2?7@C5 (9:E69625[ #@??:6 (9:E69625[ 2?5 s6H2J?6 (9:E69625 @7 w@33D[ }|]k^Am
kAms2G:5 :D DFCG:G65 3J 9:D H:76 @7 b_ J62CD[ t=@:D (9:E69625j D:I 49:=5C6?i 52F89E6CD |@?:42 |6CC:6EE 2?5 9FD32?5 s2G:5 @7 }6H6==E@?[ {p[ {2FC2 sFAFJ 2?5 9FD32?5 y@9? @7 {:55:6G:==6[ {p[ r9C:DE:6 !2C<6C @7 (:??D3@C@j D@?Di r925 (9:E69625 @7 }6H |6I:4@[ s6CJ== (9:E69625 @7 }6H |6I:4@[ 2?5 zC:DE@A96C (9:E69625 @7 s6?G6C[ %)j aa 8C2?549:=5C6?[ `a 8C62E\8C2?549:=5C6?[ D:DE6C y6C: $9@27 2?5 9FD32?5 #2=A9 @7 q=24<7@@E[ xsj 3C@E96C q:==J (9:E69625 @7 w@33D[ }|j 2?5 >2?J @E96C 7C:6?5D 2?5 72>:=J]k^Am
kAm~?=:?6 4@?5@=6?46D >2J 36 >256 2E k2 9C67lQ9EEAi^^HHH]56??2C57:CDE?2E:@?2=]4@>QmHHH]56??2C57:CDE?2E:@?2=]4@>k^2m ]k^Am
kAm(:==6?6 z:?42:5 tG2?Dk^Am
kAm(:==6?6 z:?42:5 tG2?D H2D 3@C? u63CF2CJ h[ `haf 2?5 C2:D65 :? (:??D3@C@[ E96 J@F?86DE 52F89E6C @7 #@36CE “u@DE6C” 2?5 |26 z:?42:5] $96 2EE6?565 (:??D3@C@ D49@@=D[ 8C25F2E:?8 :? `hcd] $96 2EE6?565 3FD:?6DD D49@@= :? w@FDE@?[ %6I2D[ H9:=6 =:G:?8 H:E9 “$:DE6C”[ y6DD:6 |26 2?5 q:== pC6J] k^Am
kAm(:==6?6 >2CC:65 $:5?6J {@F:D tG2?D @? y2?F2CJ aa[ `hcf] %96J =:G65 :? (:??D3@C@ F?E:= $:5?6J H2D 42==65 324< :?E@ 24E:G6 5FEJ 7@C E96 z@C62? (2C :? `hd_[ H96C6 96 H2D DE2E:@?65 :? $63C:?8[ u=@C:52] p=E9@F89 E96J C6EFC?65 E@ (:??D3@C@ 27E6C 9:D 5:D492C86 :? `hd`[ 5FC:?8 E96:C C6>2:?:?8 >2CC:65 =:76 E96J 2?5 E96:C 8C@H:?8 72>:=J 2=D@ =:G65 :? |2CD92==E@H?[ x@H2[ pC=:?8E@?[':C8:?:2[ |6DBF:E6[ sF?42?G:==6 2?5 vC2?5 !C2:C:6[ %6I2D] $96 2?5 $:5?6J >@G65 324< E@ E96 (:??D3@C@ 2C62 FA@? C6E:C6>6?E :? `hgc] x? a__c[ D96 >@G65 E@ vFE9C:6[ ~<=29@>2 H96C6 D96 C6D:565 F?E:= 96C 562E9 @? |2J ae[ a_a`]k^Am
kAm$96 :D AC646565 :? 562E9 3J 96C =@G:?8 9FD32?5[ $:5?6J[ EH@ 8C2?5D@?D[ t==:@EE s2?:6= tG2?D 2?5 s@?2=5 #2J “$4@@E6C” #2>D6J[ 96C A2C6?ED[ u@DE6C 2?5 |26[ 96C D:DE6C y6DD:6 |26 pC6J[ 2?5 3C@E96CD[ r2C6J[ tG6C6EE 2?5 #@36CE “s6>A” $96 H2D 2=D@ AC646565 :? 562E9 3J ?F>6C@FD ?:646D 2?5 ?6A96HD[ :?4=F5:?8 96C G6CJ =@G:?8 ?:646[ w2CC:6E z:?42:5 $E2AA]k^Am
kAm(:==6?6 :D DFCG:G65 3J 96C 49:=5C6?[ #@??J tG2?D[ {6H:DG:==6[ %6I2D[ s2? tG2?D W$FD2?X[ |F=92==[ ~<=29@>2[ $92C@? |2C4FD[ yF?4E:@? r:EJ[ z2?D2D[ z6??J tG2?D Wz2C6?X 2?5 p=2? tG2?D[ p=G2C25@[ %6I2D] $FCG:G:?8 8C2?549:=5C6? 2C6 (6D=6J |2:>@?6[ p>2?52 tG2?D {2??@? Wv6@C86X[ %@55 w2CC:D WtC:<2 $49?6:56CX[ yF=:2 w2?5E qJ6CD Wy@?2E92?X[ {:D2 w2?5E[ |6892? tG2?D (256 W{2CCJX[ 2?5 p?56=J? tG2?D s6=825@ W#2A926X=] $96 2=D@ :D DFCG:G65 3J D6G6?E66? 8C62E\8C2?549:=5C6? 2?5 EH@ 8C62E\8C62E 8C2?549:=5C6?] $FCG:G:?8 2=D@ 2C6 ?:646D[ ':C8:?:2 z:?42:5 t55=6>2? 2?5 q2C32C2 z:?42:5 (256[ 2?5 ?6A96H {6G2? z:?42:5 2?5 ?F>6C@FD ?:646D 2?5 ?6A96HD 3J >2CC:286]k^Am
kAm(:==6?6 H2D 2 =:76=@?8 >6>36C @7 E96 (:??D3@C@ u:CDE &?:E65 |6E9@5:DE r9FC49] k^Am
kAmx? =:6F @7 7=@H6CD[ 4@?EC:3FE:@?D E@ E9:D 49FC49 >2J 36 8:G6? :? 96C ?2>6 :? >6>@C:2>]k^Am
kAmuF?6C2= D6CG:46D H:== 36 96=5 @? yF?6 `a[ a_a` 2E ` A> 2E |F=962C? uF?6C2= r92A6= :? (:??D3@C@[ {@F:D:2?2 H:E9 !2DE@C qC25=6J $H:C6 AC6D:5:?8] k^Am
kAmx?E6C>6?E H:== 36 96=5 2E E96 |JCE=6 |6>@C:2= 46>6E6CJ]k^Am
(0) comments
Welcome to the discussion.
Log In
Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.